Informal NYer poll-offensive word

mullaney

IRC Administrator
Staff member
#21
Strange... I'm trying to think why someone would be offended in a personal way by the use of the word. I could see someone being repulsed by the word if their mental picture for the word was a used condom. When I think of a word as offensive, it's usually because it's a slur against a particular group like "fag", "kike" or "cunt". If someone thinks that scumbag is offensive, what group do they think it offends? Low-level criminals? Guys who use condoms?
 
#22
Maybe it's an anti-condom thing? More offensive to those who think the use of condoms is sinful...?


Strange... I'm trying to think why someone would be offended in a personal way by the use of the word. I could see someone being repulsed by the word if their mental picture for the word was a used condom. When I think of a word as offensive, it's usually because it's a slur against a particular group like "fag", "kike" or "cunt". If someone thinks that scumbag is offensive, what group do they think it offends? Low-level criminals? Guys who use condoms?
 

Masten

The verbal Herman Munster
#23
Strange... I'm trying to think why someone would be offended in a personal way by the use of the word. I could see someone being repulsed by the word if their mental picture for the word was a used condom. When I think of a word as offensive, it's usually because it's a slur against a particular group like "fag", "kike" or "cunt". If someone thinks that scumbag is offensive, what group do they think it offends? Low-level criminals? Guys who use condoms?
Well, by that logic no one should mind being called a douchebag either.
 

mullaney

IRC Administrator
Staff member
#24
Well, by that logic no one should mind being called a douchebag either.
Perhaps they shouldn't, and yet that word does feel a bit sexist, and I would be less likely to use douchebag in some settings that I'd feel free to use scumbag. Perhaps it's because douche clearly has a connection to private parts while scum can mean lots of different things. If people use scum commonly to refer to anything that has to do with sexuality, it's news to me. It wasn't until this thread that I ever thought scumbag meant a used condom. I would have guessed it had to do usages like, "He's the scum of the earth."
 

mullaney

IRC Administrator
Staff member
#27
I think "scum" as an insult, even as in "scum of the earth", is semen, making a scumbag a condom.

I just think it's such a dated association that only very old people would make it.
I think you have semen on the brain. Scum is not even close to a synonym for semen.
 

Hal Phillips

I Am Hal Phillips
#28
I think you have semen on the brain. Scum is not even close to a synonym for semen.
It's a disgusting film of liquid filth. The dictionary says "a film or layer of foul or extraneous matter that forms on the surface of a liquid".

That's not semen, so you're right. But I feel like it's close enough for people to call a used condom a scumbag, as long as they're not chemists.
 

Gwyn

Old School
#29
I was told the used condom definition was a NY thing. And that is why it's -I used the word "offensive" but maybe should have said - stronger and more vulgar, to them than to me, for instance.

Douche/douchebag, I don't find offensive. Maybe I should. Maybe that's part of a sexism that's so ingrained even I totally accept and expect it.

I do, however, find them interchangeable. So it's funny to me when someone finds douche okay, but douchebag offensive.

Here's another one for you, not specific to NY though---
Dork.

Apparently that used to be a pretty common word for penis. The story I heard was of parents in the 60's and 70's blanching when their kids went around calling other kids "dorks".
I mean, to us it was like "nerd". Or maybe, a dumb nerd, because generally "nerd" had that bookish/smart connotation, and "dork" did not.
 
#30
I still use "dork" in the old way when talking to my parents, because they haven't caught on to the new use of it and I don't want to confuse them.
 
#31
I think you have semen on the brain. Scum is not even close to a synonym for semen.
This exact same question ("scumbag" as offensive reference) came up in an issue of Copy Editor I read once, and it said that at one time "scum" was slang for semen. I can't really google "semen" to back this up right now as I'm at work.
 

El Jefe

latitudinarian
Staff member
#35
This is from the Online Etymology Dictionary:

scum
1326 (implied in scummer "shallow ladle for removing scum"), from M.Du. schume "foam, froth," from P.Gmc. *skuma- (cf. O.N. skum, O.H.G. scum, Ger. Schaum "foam, froth"), perhaps from PIE base *(s)keu- "to cover, conceal" (see hide (n.1)). Sense deteriorated from "thin layer atop liquid" to "film of dirt," then just "dirt." Meaning "lowest class of humanity" is 1586; scum of the Earth is from 1712. Adopted in Romanic, cf. O.Fr. escume, Mod.Fr. écume, Sp. escuma, It. schiuma. Adj. scummy first attested 1577; transf. sense of "filthy, disreputable" is recorded from 1932. Slang scumbag "condom" is from 1967; meaning "despicable person" is from 1971.
 
#38
This sounds similar to being outraged by insults to your mother. That switch did not get flipped in my brain. You have to be pretty specific and accurate in your insults to enrage me.

I associate knee-jerk anger at arbitrary insults with low intelligence or an eagerness to be offended.
 
#39
One time a garbage man Yelled to his buddies that I must have "a degree in Dumbology", which was very insulting because I never graduated from college.

Another time, a lady told me to "go back to jersey!", but I live in Westchester.
 
Top