161 W. 22nd
I started reading this thread and it made me sort of sad for the old theater at 161. That's where all the shows I loved the most happened.
The first sketch show I saw at the UCB was Mr A$$, way back in 2001, and it was just awesome. Their interpretive movement scene set to "Come Sail Away" still makes me laugh. Bret did his character, Ridiculous Larry, who was disturbingly obsessed with Haley Joel-Osmet. That show is still something that I hold up as an ideal of what sketch should be- smart, fast paced, with loud kickass music. They were so great to watch, I wish they'd do another show together.
The first Manson Roast show was also great; they worked so hard and wrote such good stuff. They were an inspiration to a lot of people because they were only in level 2 when they did it. Mike Arauz was so great in that show as a rogue Jesus clone. I think that was the one where Brian Fountain played Tard Dad? Great work by all of them.
Curtis and John's roommate sketch, with that grabber claw...I loved that. I would always try to peer out from the curtains backstage and see it when we were all in Ian's show. They did it in their own show as well, which was also fabulous. An excellent use of jellybeans.
Someone mentioned the Dogs of St. Christopher- I thought Andy Rocco and Zack were amazing as well. But my favorite moment in the show has to have been when Chris Gethard was spurned in the love triangle between he, Molly, and Tarik's characters. After walking in on Molly and Tarik in her motel room in a failed attempt to make a pass at her, Chris's character tried to play it cool by saying, "I'll just be down here...sniffing the vents." That was the actual line he said in the improv scene, and Delaney immediately put it in the script. It broke my heart that first time he did it and each time he said it onstage. It still makes me laugh and cry a little at the same time.
Totally Useless Side Note- the music for the show was picked by the cast and by Delaney. There were two ELO songs included- "Strange Magic" & "Telephone Line". As a charter member of the ELO Preservation Society, I consider this a significant fact.